Consultation
Home Know-how Heating compared
CSENDENL PLHRFRIT
camperinvest.com · 8 languages
From experience

Motorhome heating compared: Scheer Nano vs Alde 4000D

Hydronic diesel heating keeps a large motorhome warm through a water circuit and doubles as the hot-water supply. This is a practical comparison of a newcomer, the Scheer Nano with its blue burner, against a long proven unit, the Alde 4000D (Compact 4000D).

Scheer Nano

Scheer Nano diesel water heater
Scheer Nano · courtesy Scheer Heizsysteme

Alde 4000D (Compact 4000D)

Alde Compact 4000D water heater
Alde Compact 4000D · courtesy Alde

Pros and cons

Scheer Nano

Pros
  • Higher maximum output, 7 kW.
  • State-of-the-art combustion with soot-free running.
  • High efficiency, 93 to 94 %, and lower fuel consumption.
  • Automatic altitude compensation.
  • Very compact, so easier to build in.
  • Handles alternative fuels too.
Cons
  • A new product with a shorter field history.
  • A smaller and less dense service network.
  • Spare parts are harder to obtain, especially outside Europe.
  • Higher purchase price.

Alde 4000D

Pros
  • A long proven design.
  • Wide service network and parts availability across Europe.
  • Integrated 10 l boiler.
  • Combined diesel and electric running.
  • Compatible with HVO100.
  • Standard fitment in many premium vehicles, so a deep pool of owner experience.
Cons
  • Lower maximum diesel output, 6 kW.
  • A conventional burner without blue-burner technology, so potentially higher consumption and more soot.
  • No automatic altitude compensation, according to available material.
  • Larger than the Nano.

Key differences

ParameterScheer NanoAlde 4000D
Max. power (diesel)7 kW6 kW
Electric boostup to 3 kW1 to 3 kW
Combustion technologyblue burner, soot-freeconventional burner
Compactnessvery smallstandard
Altitude compensationyes, automaticnot stated explicitly
Integrated boilernot statedyes, 10 l
Track record / servicenew company, growing networklong established, dense network

Summary

The Scheer Nano is a compelling option if you want the most modern and efficient combustion, small dimensions, and you also travel high into the mountains.

The Alde 4000D is the safer bet on a proven design, with good access to service and spare parts across Europe, which can matter on long trips.

Based on publicly available material from the manufacturers and specialist websites (scheer-heizsysteme.de, alde.com and others). Figures may vary with the specific configuration and heater version.

Not sure which heating suits your build?

We can walk your model line and the way you travel through with you, and match the heating to how you use the vehicle.